Skip to main content

Know Limitations of GST Section 73 with SCN Time Limits

Image
By Arpit Kulshrestha
GST Section 73 with Time Limits

Article 73 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act grants authority to authorized officers for the assessment of tax liability, interest, and penalties. Despite the initial three-year timeframe, subsequent amendments and notifications have prolonged deadlines, giving rise to discussions and legal controversies. 

The inclusion of Section 168A in the 2020 amendment provides the government with the ability to extend limits in cases of force majeure. Nevertheless, challenges arise from the retrospective application and interpretations of the term "force majeure," contributing to complexities and disputes, as evidenced by recent legal cases.

Research in Detail

Section 73 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act confers authority upon the designated officer to assess tax liability, interest, and penalties. Subsection (10) initially sets three years for issuing orders, yet this temporal limitation has been subject to amendments via GST notifications. 

For instance,  the original time limit for FY 2018-2019 was 31.12.2023, extended to 31.03.2024 (Notification No. 09/2023–Central Tax Dated: 31/03/2023) and later to 30.04.2024 (notification, No. 56/2023-Central Tax, dated the 28th December, 2023). For FY 2019-20, the original deadline of 31.03.2024 was extended to 30.06.2024 (Notification 09/2023) and then to 31.08.2024 (Notification 56/2023).

These extensions result from the 2020 amendment's introduction of Section 168A, which grants the government, based on Council recommendations, the authority to extend time limits due to force majeure. The retrospective applicability of this section, dating back to the Act's commencement, introduces complexities, particularly for years devoid of any force majeure events.

Read Also: Useful Tips to Keep in Mind for Handling GST Department Audit

The term "force majeure" encompasses occurrences such as earthquakes and pandemics. A debate arises regarding whether the clause "or otherwise affecting the implementation of any provisions of the Act" permits the government to extend limitations even in the absence of calamities. Some argue that this interpretation confers unchecked power for extensions unrelated to pandemics or earthquakes. However, legal principles like Ejusdem generis and Noscitur a sociis suggest that the phrase "or otherwise" should be construed in conjunction with the preceding words, confining extensions to extraordinary circumstances.

Legal disputes, exemplified by recent cases such as M/s Garg Rice Mills vs State of Punjab CWP 1138 of 2024 in the Punjab and Haryana High Court, and cases in the Gujarat High Court involving M/s SRSS Agro Pvt. Ltd. and M/s New India Acid Baroda Pvt. Ltd., underscore the challenges posed by the second extension of GST notice time limits under Section 168A. These cases shed light on arguments against unrestricted time limit extensions.

Closure: The complexities stemming from amendments and interpretations in the context of time limit extensions under Section 73 of the CGST Act highlight the challenges faced. The incorporation of Section 168A, designed to tackle force majeure situations, has sparked legal disputes and discussions regarding the extent of extensions. Current legal cases offer valuable perspectives, illustrating arguments opposing unrestricted time limit extensions and underscoring the importance of clarity and meticulous interpretation when dealing with the intricacies of GST notice time limits.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

GST: Assessees Must E-file Their Tax Returns by 30th Nov 2024 to Claim Pending ITC

By Arpit Kulshrestha
If you are a GST-registered assessee you need to consider the due date to avail of any due Input tax credit or revised errors/omissions for the FY 2023-24 is November 30, 2024, via submitting the appropriate GST forms. Missing the due date can produce an outcome of a financial loss as the unclaimed ITC could not be used to offset your output tax obligation. What is the Method to Claim the Due ITC or Revised GST Errors for the FY 2023-24 It was stressed by the tax experts that the GST law specifies the procedure to claim the due ITC via GSTR-3B and amend errors in GSTR-1. Filing GSTR-1: Errors induced in GSTR-1 can be rectified by making amendments in the following GSTR-1 filings. Filing GSTR-3B: Via the GSTR-3B return the obligated ITC can merely be claimed. November 11, 2024, was the due date to submit the GSTR-1, and November 20, 2024, is for GSTR-3B without any penalty. Both the outcomes can be provided till November 30, 2024, as per the late fees. R...
Post a Comment
Read more

How ITR Software Assists Individuals in Filing Tax Returns

By Arpit Kulshrestha
Every assessee's process of income tax return (ITR) filing is significant, as it contributes to Indian's economy. The Income Tax Department has made efforts to facilitate this approach in recent years, but numerous people still see themselves steering a difficult financial system, multiple tax deductions, miscellaneous exemptions, and changing tax laws. This complexity can turn what must be an easy task into a significant challenge. In this context, income tax software evolves into an important partner, presenting a useful variety of accuracy, efficiency, and reassurance. The software enables return filing that permits taxpayers to handle their financial responsibilities when complying with the law. 1. Accurate Tax Calculations An incorrect income tax calculation of taxes could result in messages from the Income Tax Department or missed refunds. The tax software helps in finding taxable income and tax deductions that you may be allowed, like insurance or home loans. The co...
Post a Comment
Read more

Why Small Firms Should Consider Gen Payroll Software?

By Arpit Kulshrestha
Businesses in this competitive era would be required to manage the payroll. Payroll software has multiple operations such as paying employees, following tax laws, managing employee benefits, filing important documents, and keeping accurate records. Businesses that manage tasks manually or with spreadsheets can result in inappropriate compliance and issues, wasting time in doing operations. Gen Payroll software arrives to manage payroll with accuracy and resolve the issues that come therein. The merits and demerits of Gen Payroll software are mentioned below. Gen Payroll Software Gen Payroll is a payroll management software made by SAG Infotech . It eases and automates the process of payroll. The software’s features are tracking employee attendance, calculating salaries, ensuring compliance with laws like PF (Provident Fund), ESI (Employee State Insurance), and TDS (Tax Deducted at Source), as well as generating payslips. Businesses, whether small or large, can use this software. ...
2 comments
Read more